The reports have just come in of five skiers dying in an avalanche in Austria. This is just the latest news on this front from what looks like another bad season. The incident took place in the Wattental valley, Tirol, and reports indicate that those involved had ignored warnings. The Guardian paper reported that: The experienced […]
Learning how to use an ice axe to self arrest is a key skill that may save your life in the mountains. Don’t neglect to learn and practise it. There are many good resources to learn from including the British Mountaineering Club. Read this post. Look at the techniques discussed. Check out the other resources and then, most important of all, get out and do it over and over again on the hill until you can do it in your sleep.
Anyhow, I recently came across an old Army field manual on mountaineering that shows how the American military teaches ice axe self arrest. I thought I’d post it here with a comparison of how civilian schools teach it as it is a nice way of teaching a beginner the basics and it also points out some differences between how Americans and Europeans train As you’d expect it is pretty similar stuff but there are important details of difference in how the self arrest technique is taught and practised.
Now there are a couple of really interesting points here and also a couple of points that I’d like to take exception with. For reference I’m using the Mountain Skills Training Handbook of the Association of Mountaineering Instructors (AMI), which is probably one of the main standards of civilian training in Europe. And for reference in America I refer to the Alpine Institute, which is the leading American teaching organisation.
1 The first point to note is the grip. In this image, the climber is holding the ice-axe in the correct way with the adze pointing forwards in the direction of travel. This means it can be quickly brought up to the shoulder for use. The one difference in training is that the Mountain Skills Handbook urges climbers to bring the lower hand (in this picture the climber’s left hand – though on the right from our perspective) down to cover the spike at the bottom of the ice axe. This is to prevent it from either stabbing the climber or from digging into the snow during the roll-over. For comparison see this photo below from the Mountain Skills book.
Digging in of feet during self arrest
Another big area of difference between the way that Americans and Europeans do self arrest relates to how they use their feet. In the picture at the top you will not that the climber is encourage to dig their heel in to slow themselves in preparation for the rollover (graphic 1), they then continue to dig in with one toe during the rollover and as the ice axe starts to bite and finally (3) they are positioned with both feet pointing right into the snow and digging in to slow themselves down.
The British schools teach the exact opposite. I’ve grabbed a clip here from a training video produced by the British Mountaineering Council (BMC) and posted on the web to teach proper self arrest. I’m afraid that the image I have is not great but you can see that the instructor has very clearly lifted his legs up to prevent the tips of his crampons from digging in.
The logic for keeping the feet up is to reduce the risk of a cartwheel or tumble happening if your crampons dig into the snow. I quote the official advice from the Mountain Skills book which says:
Start at the feet, getting them to raise into the air. This is for two reasons – if crampons are being worn when a fall is made, it is imperative that the crampon points do not dig into the snow. But even if crampons are not worn, there is still a chance of the front of the boot digging into the snow. Either of these scenarios could cause injury or cart-wheeling.
This all sounds perfectly sensible to me, because this is the way I learned to climb and to fall. But it is not the way it is taught in many other places. According to the Alpine Institute’s commentary on the video, they point out that they teach things differently. On the question of whether to dig in the feet they say:
There is some debate on whether you should put your feet up or not. The concern — as the guide in the video points out — is that if you put your feet down and your crampon points catch, that you might flip head-over-heels. On the other hand, it might stop you more quickly. We teach people to put their toes into the snow to arrest the fall.
One further point to note is that in the Army training manual the climber is not wearing crampons. The commentary in the manual states:
If crampons are worn, the feet must be raised to prevent the crampons from digging into the snow or ice too quickly. This could cause the climber to tumble and also, could severely injure his ankles and legs.
This sounds sensible enough except for the fact that in an emergency you behave as you’ve been trained to. If you always practise lifting your legs, then there is a good chance that when you fall and the pucker factor is high, you won’t be thinking but will do what you have trained to do. Similarly if you are used to digging your feet in, then that is what you will do. I personally recommend training by keeping your feet up. If you are not wearing crampons then hopefully you will remember to modify your position if you aren’t slowing fast enough. Frankly, though, I think that you should be focussed on putting all of your weight onto the pick and not messing about with your feet (unless you have no ice axe, in which case you’ll just have to make do and hope that hands and feet will be enough).
Look Away from the Ice Axe
A third point that I’d make about the set of pictures is that they do not show the climber looking away from the ice axe when putting weight on it and pushing into the snow. If anything, they have a head position that is turned towards the ice axe. I don’t know exactly what the standard american technique is (the excellent Traditional Mountaineering Website) offers some great tips and advice no practising but I don’t see any clear advice on this subject. (If there are any American readers I’d love to get some feedback on this)
The British technique though is to look away from the ice axe. Again the Mountain Skills book has this to say on the subject:
It is important to look in the opposite direction to the axe head – if you look towards the axe head and it catches on a section of hard ice or a rock, facial injury is a real possibility.
Ice Axe Self Arrest When Falling Head First
This is the more complex situation and it is best understood by practising the technique quite a few times. I’ll post the pictures from the Army Training Manual below and give some commentary on them too.
In this series of pictures you see how important it is to firstly try to stabilise yourself in a fall and to then rotate the head back up towards the top of the slope. Once you’ve done that you then begin to dig right in to slow the descent. Remember not to apply too much pressure immediately as you could have the ice axe ripped out of your arms before you are in a position to hold it properly.
Learning the proper ice axe self arrest technique takes a lot of practise. Spend time doing it somewhere safe and hopefully the skill will be there when you need it most.
Here are a few videos showing the correct way to self-arrest from a slide using an ice axe.
A practical guide to ice-axe arresting taken from the British Mountaineering Council’s ‘Winter Essentials’ DVD with their kind permission. Full DVD available here: www.thebmc.co.uk For more videos like this, visit www.livefortheoutdoors.com
Proper self-arrest from a backwards position.