• About and Privacy Policy

Mountaingear blog

Mountaineering gear news, reviews and tests

  • Reviews
  • Mountain Safety
  • Tips
  • About and Privacy Policy
You are here: Home / Reviews / The Jetboil Stove Reviewed: Count Me Out of This Revolution

The Jetboil Stove Reviewed: Count Me Out of This Revolution

September 23, 2005 by Jonathan Rosenthal 1 Comment

Who would have thought that something has humble as little gas canister stove would create as much of a stir as the Jetboil has. Mention this funky little cooker to someone who owns one and they’ll likely go cross-eyed and start talking about it like a lover or friend, not a darned canister stove.
Time Magazine features it among the “most amazing inventions of 2004”; Popular Science Magazine gave an innovation award to its inventors — and I haven’t even started on the climbing and outdoor press!
Outside Magazine says “the folks at JetBoil have taken the simple concept of heating water to the next level, putting out the most efficient stove ever made”.
So what is it that makes the Jetboil so special?
The designers have done some nifty work, integrating a canister, stove and pot. It’s also got some neat design tweaks. Under the pot is a heat exchanger that helps capture more warmth from the burner, while the pot itself has a built-in insulating blanket. Taken together these mean you use less gas to heat your water. The manufacturer claims an efficiency of 75 percent. You’d be hard pressed to find another stove than comes close.
I can’t argue with the concept, but I’ve always had two reservations about the Jetboil.
The first is that it’s not really suited to cooking anything more complex two cups of boiling water. It’s great if you’re camping on your own and are happy to eat freeze-dried food out of the packet, but not so cool if you’ve got a buddy and want to cook real food for two.
The second reservation is that it’s also not the useful for melting snow because it’s pot is just too darned small.
With a list of brags as long as the Jetboil’s, I just had to set aside my prejudice and check one out.
The thing I liked most about it, and this you have to see for yourself, is that it’s really light and compact. It has a listed weight of 425 grams (15 oz), which is less than the weight of many single pots. It also stows into a really compact package that’s about the size of a Nalgene bottle. All in all less than half the volume and weight of my MSR Dragonfly stove and Alpine cookset.
The pot cover and grab-handle are also a lot more robust than I’d thought. But I still like the flexibility of a liquid-fuel stove.
All in all this is a great product – but has it converted me?
Sorry, but I’m the spoilsport at this party. If I was doing big wall climbing or solo hiking and cycle touring then it could make a great choice. I prefer to get into the hills with my friends and go places where they don’t always stock gas canisters but have plenty of gasoline and kerosene. And finally I like to eat real food cooked in a real pot – not in an oversized rubberized beer mug. Call me caveman if you will and tell me that I’m turning my back on progress. Whatever. I’m sticking with my thundering MSR
Just to be fair, this is what some other folks have been saying about the Jetboil:
Backpacker Magazine says:

What makes Jetboil so lovable is its ultra-efficient design, which integrates a 1-liter insulated pot, wind-protected burner, and heat exchanger into a single rugged unit.

Rebecca Sowards-Emmerd at Backpackergeartest.org gives this summary:
 
Pros:
 – It sure boils water fast!
 – It pours well with good control when the cup is used by itself.
 – It melts snow very well.
 – It packs together very well as a system. 
Cons:
 – Removal of the bottom cover is extremely difficult.
 – It is difficult to remove the cup from the stove/fuel after use.
 – Retains some color from coffee, but so far this is just cosmetic – it hasn’t affected the flavor of the water being boiled inside.
Michael Briski also reviews the Jetboil on his website and gives it a favorable review, adding that:

the down side to this cooking system is that you have to be comfortable with doing one pot meals. If you are a great one-pot chef – this is the system for you.  

So there we have it. What do you think. If you own one, give me your thoughts.
And if you must have one they are available here:

Filed Under: Reviews, Stoves Tagged With: review, stove

About Jonathan Rosenthal

Hi
I'm an enthusiastic outdoor type of guy who unfortunately spends far too much time sitting in front of a computer and not enough time out in the hills.
This site is really about my personal passion for hiking and climbing and has nothing to do with my day job. All views expressed here are my own. If you'd like to know more about me please go to my Google page or if you would like to know more about my work visit my LinkedIn profile

Comments

  1. Anonymous says

    March 30, 2006 at 11:00 pm

    I’m curious to know your thoughts given the new GCS jetboil product soon to come out for about $100.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search this site

South Africa’s Otter Trail in the Tsitsikamma National Park in widely regarded as the country’s best hiking trail. And it is with good reason: the spectacular trail winds along the edge of the coast, offering plenty of opportunities for swimming. Each of its huts has spectacular views of the ocean.

Recent Posts

  • Hiking the South African Otter Trail
  • The Nepal insurance scam
  • ‘The bivvy bag probably saved their lives’: couple lost in Cairngorms found safe | UK news | The Guardian
  • At least two (and possibly four) killed on Scottish mountains
  • Five skiers die in Austrian avalanche

Recent Comments

  • Jonathan Rosenthal on The Alpkit Tetri
  • The Alpkit Tetri | Mountaingear blog on Terra Nova Laser Competition 1 Tent Review
  • The Alpkit Tetri | Mountaingear blog on Lightwave Wildtrek 60 Pack Review
  • Bollocky Bill on The Alpkit Tetri
  • Liam on Mountain Hardwear Trango 2 Tent

Copyright © 2023 · Metro Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in